What the listing does not show
417 Menahan Street
Brooklyn, NY 11237Walk-up apartment buildingHigh risk
Listed at $949,999. The listing does not mention what city records show: 57 open housing violations, 18 of them immediately hazardous. A buyer can put that on the table before contract. A seller should expect the question.
- Asking
- $949,999
- Beds
- 6 beds
- Baths
- 6 baths
- Size
- 1,958 ft²
- Building
- Walk-up apartment building
- Built
- 1931
- Open housing violations
- 57
- Immediately hazardous
- 18
- Open building violations
- 18
- Unresolved penalties
- 4
01 / Findings
What to ask about
City records a buyer can raise and a seller should be ready to explain. A reading of open filings, not a forecast.
- 0118 open Class C (immediately hazardous) housing violations a buyer can raise, and a seller should be ready to explain.
- 0218 open Buildings Department violations, which can slow a closing.
- 034 unresolved penalties (2 hazardous) that can follow the property into the sale.
- 04About 1,281 ft² of unused residential floor area the listing does not mention.
02 / Building
The building
Department of Finance class C2: Walk-up apartments.
- Type
- Walk-up apartment building
- Year built
- 1931
- Floors
- 3
- Units
- 66 residential
- Building area
- 3,510 ft²
- Residential / commercial
- 3,510 / 0 ft²
- Lot
- 1,970 ft²19.58 × 100 ft
- Assessed value
- $447,300Tax assessment, not market value
- Assessed land
- $4,950
- Tax exemption
- None
03 / Zoning
What the lot allows
Zoned R6. Floor area ratio is how much building the lot can legally hold. Listings rarely spell this out.
Unused residential floor area
1,281ft²
Built at 73% of allowed
Zoning would still allow this much more housing on the lot.
- Commercial FAR allowed
- 0.00
- Community facility FAR
- 4.80
- Affordable housing bonus FAR
- 3.90
- Zoning district
- R6
04 / Checked
What was checked
A zero means the file exists and is clear. A dash means the city has no file for this address, which is not the same thing.
Housing (HPD)
57
open violations
18 immediately hazardous, 27 hazardous, 12 non-hazardous, 0 informational.
Registration recently lapsed, ended Sep 1, 2026. Owner state NY.
Buildings (DOB)
18
open violations
19 safety-related. Most recent open filing Feb 24, 2017.
Permits, unsafe structures, boilers, elevators, facades.
Penalties (ECB)
4
unresolved
2 hazardous. $7,812 imposed, last issued May 7, 2026.
Unpaid balance
05 / Full report
Not on the listing
Sale prices, mortgage amounts and document amounts the city has on file. The listing does not include them.
15 recorded documents · 0 sales of $10,000 or more · Last sale none · Last mortgage none
Unlock the recorded amounts for 417 Menahan Street
After you register, the paid report includes who owns the building, plus the amounts below from the city file.
- Owner details
- Unpaid penalty balance
Paid report
The rest of 417 Menahan Street is not on the listing
After you register, the paid report names the owner. It also includes the city-file amounts the listing leaves out.
- Owner details
- Unpaid penalty balance
06 / FAQ
Questions
How many open violations does 417 Menahan Street have?
As of Oct 6, 2026, the building at 417 Menahan Street has 57 open HPD violations (18 Class C, 27 Class B, 12 Class A, 0 Class I), 18 open DOB violations, 4 unresolved ECB penalties. These are building records, so they apply to this listing.
What is the zoning of 417 Menahan Street?
The lot is zoned R6. The building is built at a floor area ratio of 1.78 against 2.43 allowed for residential use, leaving about 1,281 ft² of unused residential floor area.
Is this property in a flood zone?
No. The lot is not inside a FEMA 100-year flood zone on the 2007 or 2015 maps.
What amounts are recorded for 417 Menahan Street?
Owner details are in the paid report, available after you register. Unpaid penalty balance is in the city file and included there too.
Where does this data come from?
Records are combined from NYC DCP PLUTO (tax lot, zoning, FAR); NYC HPD (housing violations and registrations); NYC DOB and ECB (building violations and penalties); NYC ACRIS (recorded deeds, mortgages and satisfactions); Active for-sale listings. PLUTO version 26v2.
Sources
NYC DCP PLUTO (tax lot, zoning, FAR) · NYC HPD (housing violations and registrations) · NYC DOB and ECB (building violations and penalties) · NYC ACRIS (recorded deeds, mortgages and satisfactions) · Active for-sale listings
PLUTO 26v2, refreshed Oct 6, 2026. Written for people buying or selling this property. Not legal, tax, or appraisal advice. Confirm the details with the city before you offer or list.